Feldgrau.net

I noticed that you removed Sid Gutteridge's review and the attempt by Cott Tiger to engage in supposed open discussion on this forum, instead you merely deleted the posts. Funny how you didn't delete the posts of PK which were over the top until I complained. However I recently noticed that you are ...

Paddy Keathing claimed - But the majority of Waffen-SS men had nothing to do with mass-murder. However, to accept this simple fact is to risk frank and open discussion of a subject that is extremely embarrassing for everyone, especially since events have now shown us that Jews, contrary to Nazi rac...

Before you lock it maybe you could remove the defamatory material that relates to myself. As you seem to be aware of legal precendent then I would have thought as the forum hosting the comments you become a party to the action. Just a little something I picked up when I got admitted to the bar over ...

It was pretty much a certainty that you wouldn't be able to help yourself Paddy. Ah yes, the veiled threat. "I'm going to write about this forum in my second edition!" How childish. But I am sure Sid and some of the other fellow travellers will buy your second edition. If you slag off this...

Hello, Sid I must thank you for taking the time and effort to actually read the book and write a critical and unbiased review. This is exactly the type of feedback I can to this forum seeking, not the kind of rubbish that I was initally exposed to. First, you actually read the book which is a bonus ...

Is this guy serious, what an absurb comment. PK wrote. The majority of recruits to the Waffen-SS and, indeed, the SS-VT and LSSAH before them were not NSDAP members. In fact, the officer corps of the Leibstandarte-SS Adolf Hitler had to be 'persuaded' to join the party in the late 1930s for PR purpo...

Ah Pk, I know you have been waiting for this, now let me give you the answer. This is the quote that seems to have been such a bugbear. Now this is the entirety of my reference to Adenuaer in the entire book, I don't suggest his is an apologist or nazi, I am simply saying that I don't think his stat...

Tom, if you are out there I am still keen to here what you have to say. Tom, could you outline what you see the difference between camp guards and camp staff are? With regards to the Einsatzgruppen, the Waffen-SS men were transferred to them not the other way around. The movement was very fluid back...

Frederick,
now whilst I am a keen follower of US politics I am not a lover of Hillary, although she might do an alright job...

For the love of Hillary, no one asked you to reproduce the whole book here! You wrote a book and yet you can't summarize your main points?

Phylo, re the below. Terry - exactly WHAT relevance has the Waffen-SS to MODERN criminology? That's over SIXTY-THREE years ago - why not "Chopper" Read, the Unabomber, the Beltway Sniper, Son of Sam, the Atlanta Child Killer, Jeffrey Dahmer, Denis Neilsen, Peter Sutcliff, Dr. Harold Shipma...

They already had the SD, and they already had the camp guards (the difference betwixt Camp Staff, and Camp Guards is a different argument). The SS-VT which evolved into the Waffen-SS, had to be created separately. So, even from the beginning, there was a separation. Of course, Himmler blurred that ...

Yeesh! Can someone please throw in some examples from the Japanese occupation of Korea or maybe the Sumerian genocide against the Babylonians? :( It looks like any attempt to keep a narrow focus on the topic is pointless. Of course, since Valhalla has not truly defined the topic, it is no wonder. I...

And to those who think that the Waffen-SS were not political then perhaps the thoughts of Adolf Hitler may convince otherwise. The SS were independent from both the Police and the Wehrmacht, and available for Hitler’s exclusive use. To this purpose Hitler issued a secret Führer order on the 17th of ...

Now what would we say about the evidence of Mr Brill from the Leibstandarte? MR. COUNSELLOR SMIRNOV: Will you tell us, please, who was in charge of the command within the concentration-camp. Was it not the Waffen-SS? BRILL: No, they were not commands of the Waffen-SS. Certain members of the nominal ...

Hello, back again, been very busy at work lately, lots of bad people in the world you know. Now this would be an interesting question to pose I guess. What should we do about the hundreds of officers who served in the camp system and also the Waffen-SS? Should we apportion their actions in the camps...