Message forum of the Feldgrau.com research community
Moderator: Commissar D, the Evil
I suggest if you want an honest opinion of Manstein you should read the following book.julian wrote:If one wanted to know what is wrong with wikipedia, one needs only to look at the article about Manstein. At a certain point in time an individual decided to do a hatchet job on Manstein and rewrote the article to make it an anti-manstein pamphlet.
The individual did not even hide his bias as he explains it at length on the talk page of the article. Attempts by more than individual at putting the article straight, for example on the subject of what Manstein actually wrote in Lost victories, failed because a senior editor systematically removes any changes. It seems that you can get away with anything on wikipedia as long as you get in first ,refuse any changes and have a senior editor who takes your side.
The detail of what is wrong with the article is set out at length on the talk page of the article. Not that it helped. The selfappointed protector of the article wipes it all off the table using generalisations which betray that he has no proper knowledge of the subject.
Visting the article and giving it a negative rating is certainly usefull. Trying to change it is unfortunately an exercise in futility.
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 4 guests